Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Pizza Bruschetta
Bottled Beverage
Manicotti (Dinner)
Ravioli (Dinner)
About
Stromboli's New York Pizzeria
Welcome to Stromboli's New York Pizzeria, a hidden gem located at 13518 Summerport Village Pkwy, Windermere, FL. This family-run establishment shines as a beacon for pizza lovers, offering a taste of New York right in the heart of Florida. With an inviting atmosphere and a commitment to quality, Stromboli's serves up fresh, delicious pizza that keeps guests coming back for more.
Walking into Stromboli's, you can sense the warmth of family and tradition. Reviews from patrons like Doug Stroud and Jonathan Herd highlight the personal touch that this pizzeria provides. Doug raved about their daily special—two slices with a topping—and was delighted to find Mikes hot honey available for that perfect sweet and spicy kick. The passionate craft of the owners is evident, as Doug noted a charming family dynamic where different generations work together, pouring their love into every pizza.
For those seeking a casual yet memorable dining experience, Jonathan's recollection of celebrating a six-month anniversary with his wife underscores the value of Stromboli's. They enjoyed fried mushrooms and the renowned hangover pizza, paired with delectable zeppolis for dessert. This shared joy reflects what Stromboli's is all about: great food, genuine warmth, and unforgettable moments.
Moreover, patrons like Kaila Odeh and Adam Fawzy echo the sentiment that Stromboli's delivers not just in taste but also in service; the friendly staff makes every visit feel like coming home. The crispy mild wings and scrumptious garlic knots are standout offerings that satisfy cravings and pair perfectly with their freshly made pizza.
Despite its location in a bustling strip area, Stromboli's holds its own through the quality of food and the quality of the people who run it. As they say, "the family that makes pizza together stays together," and that is certainly the case here. Don’t let the lack of curb appeal deter you; the flavors within are what truly matter. Stromboli's New York Pizzeria is not just a place to grab a meal; it’s a destination where heart meets flavor, and community thrives.
Give them a call at +1 407-654-5291 and experience the authentic taste of New York pizza that you deserve!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ A very nice family run pizza place! I had one of their daily specials which consisted of two slices with one topping and a fountain drink, I opted for bottled water. The pizza was quick fresh and delicious and they even had some Mikes hot honey to add to the slices! You could tell the family that makes pizzas together stays together. There was a very nice, polite young man who was attending the customers and taking the orders. The family who appeared to be maybe a dad or granddad who was the master craftsman, then his kids or grandkids were helping in the back! Anyways very nice to see and the food was awesome, the place was clean. Only thing is curb appeal as it is located in the strip area of cornerstone and they have a sign missing, but don’t let that detour you it was great! ”
“ My wife and I wanted something low key but nice for a casual celebration at home of our six month wedding anniversary and decided to try somewhere new to us but right around the corner and could not have been happier. I’m sad how long I lived here before trying them out as the quality of food you get for the price point is very worth it. While we only entered to pick up not eat in, the environment felt like the kind of local spot that I want to support over large chains that live off their big name rather than their quality. We got fried mushrooms, chicken parmigiana with penne and a hangover pizza with zeppolis. Couldn’t be happier. ”
“ Come here frequently for lunch, good pizza quick at a reasonable price, not sure about the negative reviews but I have always had quick friendly service. ”
“ My daughter and I love this place. Great pizza, garlic knots, and zeppolis dessert ”
“ Amazing service very friendly ladies in the front, ordered the 10 mild wings were very very good cooked so good and crispy not too spicy good to my liking. ”
“ I’m trying to figure out why such low rating . I ordered the meatballs parm hero with fries and it was delicious . M from long island New York and this it’s good . I definitely will come back when in area . ”
“ My family loved the pizza! NY style was exactly what we have been looking for! Premium ingredients, great thin crust. Very happy! ”
“ Honestly it really tasted like that one spot i ate at in manhattan. This is proper nyc pizza. Amaizng 10/10. Customer service is awesome. bless up stromboli’s ”